The voting system for Albury Council elections is complicated and most Councillors have spoken out against it but what efforts have been made to change it? Perhaps it really suits most sitting Councillors and so they don’t try too hard.
So a quick explanation of how it works. Anyone can stand for election subject to certain conditions mostly relating to criminal or civil misbehaviour and there is no other test. Individual candidates are described as ungrouped and are shown at the far right of the ballot paper below the line. A candidate who forms a group with at least 5 candidates is entitled to have a group voting square above the line provided at least one other candidate requests a group voting square.
A vote is valid if at least one square is numbered above the line or at least 5 squares are numbered below the line. Past voting patterns show that 70% of voters cast their vote above the line which means that candidates without a group voting square are at a significant disadvantage. A good example of how this produces strange results can be seen from the 2008 election when Cr Angus with only 39 votes was elected on the surplus votes of Cr Gould.
A candidate can choose to advise people voting for him or her that he/she would like them to vote for other candidates in a particular order – he/she is allocating preferences. This favours sitting Councillors who can agree to swap preferences and so help each other. If a candidate gets more votes than are needed to be elected the surplus votes go to the person to whom he/she has allocated preferences. If a Councillor has surplus votes but has not allocated preferences, the extra votes are “dead” and do not continue in the count.
A fairer voting system would be preferential voting for individual candidates with no group voting. Electors would be required to vote for at least 5 candidates.
Council, in conjunction with like-minded councils should lobby the Minister for Local Government to have the system changed before the 2016 elections. It will be one of the things I will try to do if elected to Council. It should save candidates and ratepayers some money.